Elliot Lee

Hello my HP Friends,
I have a few questions.
1. Why does Harry have to go back to his aunts and uncles house?
2. Is Harry really not coming back to Hogwarts?
-Is Hogwarts even going to reopen next year?
3. Why doesn’t anbody every listen to harry
-HBLP- Snape and Malfoy.
-GOF- “The One Who Must Not Be Named” returning and so on trough out the other books.
4. Why did Dumbledore trust Snape so much?
5. What was Dumbledore drinking in the cave that made him almost die?
6. Does Harry get the Potions book before he leaves Hogwarts?
7. Is Snape really a Deatheater?
8. Excuse my langue but why is the minstery such dicks?
9. Does Harry have the same powers as “The One WHo Must Not Be Named”?
10. Does Harry Know any unforgiveable cures?
11. How will Harry try to kill “The One Who Must Not Be Named”?
12. Why did anyone check Malfoys arm for the Dark Mark?
13. Is Harry going to try and kill Snape also?
14. If Harry does not kill “The One Who Must Not Be Named” and Harry dies trying will there be a book 8?
15. Why doesnt Harry make up his own charms and potions and spells?
16. Where Harry’s parents buried or what happened to their bodies?
17. Who is RAB?
18. Is Malfoy in book number 7?
19. Why did Malfoy get in trouble for trying to use an unforgiveable curse on Harry?
20. Is Harry supose to Kill Malfoy, Snape, and The Lord all by himself?

Just a few of my question’s

Well, I don’t think anyone will read this since all of the HBP hub-bub is over, but I NEED to put my thoughts into writing.

I think JKR ended the book how she did to give herself 2 options: 1. That Dumbledore cannot really be dead (but gets snuffed in book 7) and; 2. That Snape really did kill him and he is no more, except in memories or portraits, for book 7.

JKR definitely left enough evidence for both of her options, so she could definitely do either one in book 7. Perhaps she is just waiting to hear the feedback on HBP to determine what Dumbledore’s story will be for book 7.

My questions are:

Why did Dumbledore “Freeze” Harry just before Malfoy came through the tower door? In his weakened state, wouldn’t he want more firepower on his side? Harry could have picked off every Death Eater as they came through the door while unseen beneath his invisibility cloak. Dumbledore seemed to have (and boasted about his) powerful brain, where was it at that time?

What if rendering Harry immobile was according to plan? So Dumbledore could try and persuade Malfoy, and ultimately have Snape “kill” Dumbledore in front of the Death Eaters to show that he was loyal to Voldy so Snape could gain more trust of Voldy, to then assist in the destruction of old Voldy?

The evidence for that later scenario does seem overwhelming. Dumbledore telling Malfoy that they could pretend Malfoy was killed, and then be hidden and protected by the Order of the Phoenix. He even said the same concerning Draco’s mom and dad. And who else was it that “killed” Dumbledore other than a member of the Order, whom Dumbledore thoroughly trusted? Snape could have done a lot more damage that night as well, but refrained from hexing Harry, or Hagrid, or Ron, or Hermione or anyone else that crossed his path.

It is my fear, however, that Dumbledore is gone (memories in the pensieve and his portrait notwithstanding) since it definitely fits in the overall plot of the seven-book series. He needed to die in book 6, and Harry snuffs Voldy in book 7. The only reason I think this is because when Sirius died, there was no recourse over that, it was simply “Sirius is dead, mourn your loss, and get over it, kid”. I wouldn’t be surprised if the same thing happened with Dumbledore’s death.

I don’t think Harry is a horcrux of Voldy, Dumbledore said that Voldy could not inhabit (or possess) Harry at all, that it nearly killed both of them when Voldemort attempted possession of Harry at the end of OOTP. Harry has too much love in him to for it to be possible.

I think that snape and voldemort will be killed by Harry, and Ron or Hermoine will die protecting Harry from them. I hope that snape gets kiled because if he isnt killed, i will be pretty mad.

3 words: CHECK YOUR SPELLING

Dumbledores picture is still in the Headmaster office that now will belong to Mcgonacall. I’m sure that at least one conversation in the next book between the picture and Harry will take place in the next book. Dumbledore’s too much of a main character for her write off completely. And I still think the real question about which side Snape is on it still there. If he hadn’t of killed Dumbledore he himself would of died because of the vow. Through out all of the book it has seemed like snape is evil but he turns out not to be. So I really don’t know what will happen. I just know I want no. 7 to be out soon or im gonna be pissed.