Elliot Lee

Hmm…
1.Snape isn’t a death eater( not exactly sure though )
2.Harry isn’t a horcrux
3.Maybe, just Maybe, dumbledore didn’t die? Cuz maybe he drank the draught of whatyoucallthat, the draught of living death i think.
4. Harry may die at the end
5. There isn’t a horcrux in 12 grimmauld Place, voldermort wouldn’t have put one under everybody’s nose, he knows that sooner or later somebody will find if he put’s it there.

Heh heh some of my statements were the same as Melody and rev, but that’s what i think.
Enjoy!

Think about it. This is a children’s book, so i don’t expect that this is really the end of dumbledore. Also, i still think that Snape isn’t a death eater,and what dumbledore actually meant when he said ,”Severus, please,” we won’t find out about it until the next book. I bet JK was just trying to make some suspence. I Guess she really did..

P.S: Regulus is the one who got the really got the horcurx, and Harry isn’t one. The cup that mundungus stole is a horucux. I sure of it

to all the readers who have been feeling sad about the harry - ginny breakup: after careful thought i feel that harry does not yet love ginny- its just a massive crush. i think JKR did a great thing by showing a breakup. it just sets the plot for the grand finale.
Ginny loves harry. But Harry needs to fall in love with her to be able to feel the real power of love. thats how they will be able to come together & fight Voldemort with this powerful weapon.
Comments?

and BTW i agree, Thank you JKR for making us * read & * think!

cheers…..

I’m glad that I read these comments, because I was so bummed out to read Dumbledore dying and Snape being the one to do it. I now am under the belief that Snape killed Dumbledore as an ally, and not as an enemy. I wonder if the reason that Dumbledore trusts Snape so deeply is because Snape did an unbreakable vow with Dumbledore to serve him. So Snape could have had 2 unbreakable vows, each seemingly different, but both with the same results - to kill Dumbledore.

One more thought about this. Dumbledore said he cared about Harry in the previous book… could that have actually been love, and in dying, he has given an even stronger flow of love through his blood??

I wondered about the house-elf disapparation thing too, but I remember in one of the books it stated that house-elfs had older and more powerful means of magic, they just don’t use it. Could explain disapparation I guess.

Regulus Black was killed by Voldemort (or one of this death eaters) as in book 5, so maybe he was a double agent also.

The part of people was turned into ghosts when dying was explained earlier too… basically, the only wizards who stay are ones who are afraid of death and want to stay on earth. Most wizards understand it’s just a next step, so therefore Harry’s Mom and Dad just wanted to move on.

Finally finshed the book. I really haven’t figured out whether I liked this book all that much. ( I did, and I didn’t) Some of the book seemed as if JKR had a bit of difficultiy with development. Don’t get me wrong, the book was developed quite well, and the ending tied up quite nicely. My problem would be with the long drawn out introduction, It seemed that you could cut the book in half and the you would stil get the jist of the story.

My other thought as well would lie with Snape. Did he really kill Dumbledore? It would seem that the way the book ends that there would be more then seven books? Is JKR really going to kill the golden goose that is the HP franchise? I know she said that there was only going to be seven books, but it’s not writen in stone. It seems like the seveth book would have to be twice as long as the six in order to wrap things up.

My wife believes that when the seveth book is released, the store will branch off into separate books with the three characters off to right the wrongs of the magical world.

My question to all: do you believe that Dumbuldore is really dead? Can he be really alive behind the scenes on the prusuit of He who most not be named? It would be easier for him if everyone believed he was no more? It was also explain Snape’s character: Everyone believed him to be evil, hence he is capable of doing such a haneuse act. Perfect cover for Dumbuldore’s plans. He could also want to motivate Harry Potter into action?
Now, before being flamed, I’m only asking questions: Just posing a “what if situation”. Let me know what you think? I would be most interested to know if anyone else has somewhat the same notion?

Peace, and greatings from Brooklyn!!!!